hope-voice-api/.artifacts/20260831-105824-plan-code-ui-audit/iterations/02-review.md

Review Report

• Task: 20260831-105824-plan-code-ui-audit
• Agent: reviewer
• Model: openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol
• Effort: high
• Scope: retrospective verdict on iteration 02 before iteration 03
• Verdict: changes-requested

Findings

1. High — transcript dedupe remained asymmetric and unbounded. Sources/LiveKit/TranscriptHandler.swift:36-65 handles primary→data only when the matching final is last, while data→primary duplicates; TranscriptHistory.swift:25-36 permanently suppresses adjacent legitimate repeats. Iteration 03 item 1 is required.
2. High — microphone interruption ownership was incorrect. The iteration-02 baseline resumed based on isMuted, which could unmute a user-muted mic. The current partial flag still lacks disconnect/new-interruption cleanup (VoiceSession.swift:55-57, :378-420). Iteration 03 item 2 is required but not yet complete.
3. High — media interruption was unsafe. MediaPlayerController.swift:63-76 ignores .shouldResume, and polling/reconcile (:166-178, :215-228) can immediately restart media during an interruption. Iteration 03 item 3 is required.
4. Medium — 206 content length used the returned range length, not total resource size. Iteration 03 item 4 correctly identifies the defect. The current attempted correction at PinnedMediaResourceLoader.swift:94 does not compile and therefore is not accepted.
5. Medium — MediaAPI.streamURL incorrectly fetched progressive bytes as text in the iteration-02 baseline. Iteration 03 item 5 is correct; the current MediaAPI.swift:185-190 construction-only version resolves it, though the helper has no callers.
6. High — failed/retry lifecycle remained incomplete. A final agent timeout sets failed without room/wake-lock teardown (VoiceSession.swift:182-193), and retry can reuse that room (:109-131). This was missing from iteration 03.
7. High — text mode could locally re-enable the mic. The ready-state mic toggle remains active in text mode (ConversationView.swift:97-108). This was missing from iteration 03.
8. Medium — transcript persistence/clear claims remained false in UI. Persisted entries are never rendered and Clear only clears storage (ConversationView.swift:33-37; OrbView.swift:64-107). This was missing from iteration 03.
9. Medium — state inference contradicted the current web reference. speaking→thinking can stick (ConversationState.swift:54-66) whereas web/app.js:414-426 explicitly fixed it to speaking→listening. This was missing from iteration 03.

Acceptance Criteria

• The iteration-02 changes correctly fixed the no-op text binding, open-partial replacement, desired-state assignment/gate, deterministic reconcile seam, independent join sync, and stop track-ID capture.
• They did not establish complete correctness for transcript dedupe, interruptions, retry lifecycle, reporting/stale callbacks, persistence UI, or full PLAN/UPDATE_PATH parity.
• Historical coder evidence reports 12 tests passed and a successful simulator build for iteration 02. That evidence is accepted as historical only; it does not approve behavior and cannot be rerun against the current partially modified tree.

Verification Evidence

• Reviewed iterations/01-request.md, 01-implementation.md, 02-request.md, 02-implementation.md, current complete diff, tests, product sources, and reference server/web code.
• Current XcodeBuildMCP test_sim and build_sim both fail compiling PinnedMediaResourceLoader.swift:94; this failure belongs to unreported partial iteration-03 work, not the documented iteration-02 snapshot.
• Exact current evidence and completion matrix are in ../review.md.

Residual Risks

• No real-device qualification.
• Historical iteration-02 tests omit VoiceSession lifecycle/interruption, ControlChannel protocol, persistence restoration, TLS/config, accessibility, and exact media reporting behavior.
• The current worktree no longer represents a clean iteration-02 state because iteration-03 edits are already present without an implementation report.

Required Actions

• Treat iteration 02 as changes-requested, not approved.
• Complete iteration 03 plus the missing high/medium findings listed above, restore a passing current build/test suite, and request another independent review.